Why do I need PowerGuard now?
When
QSI started making electronics for 3-Rail engines in 1989, Lionel
transformers like the ZW were the most powerful available. Our 3-Rail
electronics were designed to work with, and were tested with, these
transformers.
In 1995, many new transformers started rolling out.
Lionel®, MRC®, Right of Way®, and MTH® all introduced new transformers and
controllers. These modern transformers are powerful, easy to use and include
many new, exciting ways to run your trains. However, some of these transformers
produce continuous voltage over 35 volts, which shortens the life of 3-Rail
electronics considerably. Some transformers produce powerful killer voltage
spikes, burning out electronic components quickly. Some produce both
over voltages and killer spikes. Other transformers produce distorted waveforms
or weak horn/bell remote control signals. Some do not shut off completely when
the throttle is down.
These
problems can affect how engines respond to commands, and some problems will
damage 3-Rail electronics.
What are killer spikes and why do they happen?
A
killer spike is any transformer voltage spike that exceeds the 3-Rail
electronic component's voltage limits.
Spikes
occur when the current flow from the transformer is interrupted. Derailments,
shorts from passing over switches, bumps that cause the engine's wheels or
roller to loose contact with the rails, and hitting the direction button
quickly can all cause spikes. When the current is interrupted, the transformer
voltage immediately goes up, trying to force the current to continue. That's
what's going on when you see sparks from the wheels or rollers.
Spikes
are common, and so long as the spikes stay under 35 volts, no damage to 3-Rail
electronics will happen. But spikes from transformers can go much higher than
35 volts, depending on the amount of current being interrupted, how much load
is on the track from lighted cars or accessories, and the type of transformer.
Derailments that don't stop the train can cause very large spikes because as
the derailed truck is dragged along, the transformer rapidly produces a series
of spikes that sometimes go as high as 80 volts. Killer spikes will damage
3-Rail electronics if they're not stopped.
So what exactly does PowerGuard do?
Special circuitry
in PowerGuard watches for a quick escalation in voltage, and suppresses the
voltage before a killer spike can develop. Any spike or voltage over 35 volts
is held to a safe level. Wise people protect their home computers from damaging
voltage coming through a wall socket with a surge suppressor. In a similar way,
wise model railroaders add PowerGuard to protect expensive 3-Rail electronic
computers from damaging transformer voltage.
Does that mean I can add a regular surge suppressor to my
transformer and protect my engines?
It's always a
good idea to add a surge suppressor to protect your transformer. But surge suppressors
can only protect the transformer from high voltages coming through the wall
socket. Regular surge suppressors do not detect and suppress the voltage the
transformer sends to the layout.
How can I tell if PowerGuard is working?
The
red light on PowerGuard flashes every time the start of a voltage jump is
detected. These voltage jumps could become killer spikes, damaging the engine's
electronics. The red flash does not mean your transformer needs repair, just
that a quick increase in voltage was detected and held to a safe level.
Moving
the throttle arm up quickly can increase the voltage quickly enough make the
red light flash.
If
you use SideKick II, you will notice the red light flashing two or three times
when you press the Select/Boost button. Again, PowerGuard is reacting to a
quick increase in voltage when that button is pushed. SideKick II is not
creating or sending killer spikes itself.
Will I notice any change in how my engine behaves when I
use PowerGuard?
No. PowerGuard
uses very little power. Using PowerGuard will not change the speed, dim the
lights, or affect the sounds on your engines.
What else does PowerGuard do?
Along
with suppressing damaging transformer voltages, PowerGuard is a visual
voltmeter, showing the voltage or signal strength your transformer is
delivering. Two green lights brighten and dim as you use the throttle arm,
showing total track voltage. When you press the horn or bell button, one light
brightens and the other dims. You can quickly tell if the transformer is
working properly, and if the horn or bell buttons are sending strong, clear
signals.
Those
two green lights are especially helpful if you are programming engines with QSI
systems using Lionel's Cab-1 walk around throttle. You need to know the track voltage
to program QSI systems. Since the Cab-1 red throttle
knob has no stop, you can't tell what voltage it's serving up. PowerGuard's two
green lights brighten when Cab-1 is sending high voltage, so you can program
your engines easily.
What does the switch on PowerGuard do?
The
switch helps solve incompatibility problems between Lionel's Cab-1/PowerMaster™
and MTH ProtoSound® engines. To solve software incompatibility, first convert
your ProtoSound engine to QS-2+ (available from QSI). If the ProtoSound horn
goes off randomly when you're running your train, you still have hardware
incompatibility problems. Flip the switch on PowerGuard to "
PowerMaster" and the problem is solved.
With
all other transformers, leave the switch in the "ZW" position.
Do I need to use PowerGuard with all my transformers?
Yes.
QSI connects PowerGuard to every transformer on our test layout, old and new.
In
the past 12 years, only five QSI systems had failed from excess voltage or
spikes. We thought this was because older transformers did not produce the
killer spikes capable of burning out 3-Rail electronics. Further testing shows
all transformers, old and new, produce spikes. In fact, our ZW produced more
spikes than the new MTH Z4000. However, the spikes from the older transformers
usually do not last as long, and are not as powerful. This is because the old
transformers send out less power. Because the spikes are less powerful, fewer
QSI systems failed. Since the new transformers are more powerful, the spikes
are more powerful, and 3-Rail electronics are more quickly damaged.
Do I need PowerGuard if I'm using 3-Rail electronics made
by other manufacturers?
All the 3-Rail
electronics we know of use components and design techniques that depend on the
track voltage not exceeding 35 volts. We've also had reports of problems with
non-QSI products used with these transformers. So all 3-Rail electronics are at
risk.
I've been using my new transformer for some time now, and
the engines run fine. Do I still need PowerGuard?
Sometimes damage
from modern transformers takes a while to show up. QSI reverse units and sound
systems are tough enough to take some spikes and overvoltages, but eventually
component life span and effectiveness are affected. There is no way to tell if
damage has been done until the unit misbehaves or fails.
Why not make QSI products tough enough to take the extra
voltage from modern transformers?
We
can design a system to work with these new transformers, but that will not
solve the problem. The real problem is that 3-Rail manufacturers have not
agreed upon a common electrical standard. So, we can make a system that works
with today's transformers, but what about tomorrow's?
Second,
there are over 500,000 QSI reverse units and sound systems out there. A new
design won't help those people.
Third,
beefier electronics cost more and take more space.
PowerGuard
is a solution that works for everyone.
How can I get more information on PowerGuard?
QSI tested
PowerGuard with several transformers and wrote a technical report on our
findings. The QSI Technical Report on PowerGuard is available from QSI for $15.
An abbreviated
six-page version of the same report is on our web site at www.qsindustries.com.
The testing was
done by two electrical engineers with over 50 combined years of experience. The
full report is 64 pages, and includes 58 photos of oscilloscope waveforms.
Please call the number below if you would like to order a copy.
QSIndustries, Inc.
3800 SW Cedar Hills Blvd. Suite #224
Beaverton, OR 97005
Phone: (503) 350-0595 FAX: (503)
626-9995
http://www.qsindustries.com
© QSIndustries, Inc. 1998.
Lionel, PowerMaster, & Cab-1 are trademarks of Lionel, LLC. PowerGuard,
QS-2+, & PowerTrak are trademarks of QSI, Inc. MTH and ProtoSounds are
registered trademarks of Mike's Train House, Inc. All other trademarks are the
property of their respective owners.
Revised 1/6/99 LIS 173
|